Showing posts with label A Game of Thrones Season 3. Show all posts
Showing posts with label A Game of Thrones Season 3. Show all posts

Sunday, April 6, 2014

Game of Thrones 3.10: Part II "Mhysa"

It's kind of last minute, but:

Part II  of "Mhysa", would have included stories of Jaime Lannister, Jon Snow, and Bran/Jojen/Meera and of course Hodor, Kings Landing, and Dany. I have not checked out this blog in a while, but apparently I never completed it, so here is the short version.

My next post will be for predictions for Season 4, ie. how i think the episodes will unfold.

Jaime, Brienne & The Return to Kings Landing
We find Jaime spending a bit of time w/Qyburn.

Qyburn is the reason that Jaime's injury has been healing so well.  We get to see his wound as he cleans it and puts another bandage on it.  But Qybrun also shares that he has performed some experiments on living people, in order to learn more about how to treat them. He also implies that he does unthinkable things to living people, who are not sick or dying. Jaime's kind of horrified, but they have this great little conversation:

Qyburn: How many people have you killed?
Jaime: (thinks for a moment), I can't really say.
Qyburn: How many people have you saved?
Jaime: 500,000, the population of Kings Landing.

It is after this conversation that Jaime returns to Harrenhal and saves Brienne from the bear. I would have loved, if they had kept the moment when Brienne asks Jaime why he came back, and he says "I dreamed of you".  In the book, he says that he was going to lie, and was like screw it, I'll just tell her the truth. This event was a major turning point for Jaime.

As soon as he arrives at Kings Landing, he goes to see Cersei, who seems to be gazing lovingly, at what I would guess are King Sociopath's baby toys. He walks in and says "Cersei", and she just turns, looks at him, and he looks down, shrugs, and it was not a nasty look, but it was almost glowering. Yeah, and in S4, you'll see how losing that hand, has given him much needed clarity. It's like I said: it was the best thing to ever happen to him.

"Hey babe, I'm home!"
The Wall
Sam, Gilly, and Bran/Hodor, Jojen and Meera, bump into each other at the Wall. Bran & Co. have decided to go beyond the Wall, as that is where Bran will find the three eyed crow. Sam leads them through a tunnel, and that is where they part ways. He also, in a brilliant move, gives them all of the obsidian daggers. You know the ones that kill the White Walkers?

Eventually, after settling Gilly in, sending out the birds to warn the realm about the White Walkers, Jon shows up. 

Jon Snow
Well, they have not handled his character that well, because he is an amazing one, and my favorite. I have always complained about the lack of Ghost, as he is essential to understand his character.

We find Jon, who is on his way home, stops for water, and Ygritte finds him. Naturally she is a woman scorned, and shoots 3 arrows into him, so he is a mess when he returns to the Wall.


"You know nothing Jon Snow"
"Sam, I"m home! Oh, and my wildling girlfriend shot me."

In the book, he thinks that she shoots him, and it's one arrow, in the thigh, and he doesn't stop for water. It is also when he escapes with the help of Summer (Bran is a warg, remember?). Book Jon, is much smarter than HBO Jon, whose character development had better be back on track, as this is Jon's season.

Dany
Well, Astapor kicked off the Dany "Let's Free all of the Slaves, and start Civil Wars", tour.  She destroys cities, sets up puppet governments and frees slaves as she rages through Slavers Bay. 

We leave her with cries of "Mhysa", as she frees the slaves of yet another city, Yunkai. She stands with Messandei, and her boys: Ser Jorah, Ser Barristan, and of course her future lover, and mercenary extraordinaire, Darrio Naharis, waiting for the slaves to leave the city. She sends the dragons away, and then walks into the crowd. 

Dany: Mother of Dragons, & Rockstar of Yunkai

We will eventually see her in Meereen, where she will rule, until the end of ADWD. We can see the crazy settling in, as she leaves disease and chaos in her wake. Oh, and she can no longer control her dragons, Drogon is the most dangerous, and everybody's trying to kill her.  See you in Mereen!

Kings Landing
Our last scene of Sansa is when she has learned of her brother and mothers' deaths. Then we have one of the best scenes ever: King Tywin's council. Boy is it a fun one, because King Sociopath is smiling with glee, as he has won the war, and TALKS down to Grandpa Tywin. Everyone, even Tyrion looks like they are going to be sick, and King Tywin is having none of it: 

"Any man who must say 'I am the King', is no true king. I'll make sure you understand that when I've won the war for you." 

He asks Maester Pycelle to give him some "essence of nightshade", aka warm milk, because King Sociopath is so very tired. 

King Tywin: loving grandfather, and master of genocide

We have a great scene where Tyrion tells his father that "The North Never Forgets" and there will be repercussions for the Red Wedding. After all, Tyrion is the smartest of the Lannisters, and they have an actual conversation! It is about the Red Wedding, and what they will do, with the North decimated. This is when Lord Tywin, in his infinite wisdom, tells Tyrion, about what is now, his second act of genocide: 

"Well, we had to get rid of the Starks, and it was going to be too expensive to fight on the battlefield. So, I got the best patsy ever, Lord Frey, and the greedy, Lord "traitorous ass" Bolton, to take care of it for me. It was so much cheaper, to have a wedding, and kill everyone there. "

As always, it is so heartwarming to hear him tell Tyrion how much he hates him, and that he tried to drown him after he was born. But, sadly, he remembered that Tyrion was a Lannister, and saved his life. Thus setting the stage for Tyrion's deeply seeded anger, and resentment, that will continue to grow in S4. 

That's it! Next up, S4 predictions!

*All Images and Quotes courtesy of HBO's "Game of Thrones" 3.10



Sunday, June 23, 2013

Game of Thrones 3.10: Part I "Mhysa"

So, we are finally here, the end of season 3! and 1/2 of the awesome book that is ASOS.
This has been an amazing season and hands down the best. I have been really excited about what they have done with the material so far, and Season 4 is just too far away!

Since I did not do recaps of 3.07 & 3.08, I just merged parts of them to complete the stories in 3.10. So there will be a Part II, and finally a conclusion with predictions.

Introduction

As I had mentioned in my 3.09 posting, I was underwhelmed by last week's version of the Red Wedding. I am still upset at the brutality of Talisa's death as it overshadowed that of Robb and Cat. It bears repeating that 3.09 should have faded to black, and the shock of Robb & Cat's death, should have been the first thing on my mind. But I was still horrified by the manner in which Talisa, a pregnant woman was murdered, and she was a replacement for a book character.

I will preface this by saying that I am not some hard core feminist, but if the below is true, I find it offensive and unnecessary. I do not see any sexy guys taking their shirts off, who are non book characters and dying a miserable, brutal death, do you?

That being said, I need to reiterate a statement that I had made about the character of Roz, and the manner in which she was murdered.  It was my hope that the writers did not create her character, and waste valuable screen time, so she could be used as a reminder of the sexual proclivities of King Sociopath.  But by developing another "fake character" like Talisa, it proves that I may be correct in this assumption. The writers wrote this character solely for the purpose of using her death, as a way to increase  the shock value that they felt was needed for the Red Wedding.

The use of Talisa, rather than Jeyne Westerling was a decision, that did nothing but turn Robb Stark into a man that Roose Bolton and Lord Frey referred to as "arrogant" and "pompous" for styling himself as the "young wolf" and "King of the North".  It is an extreme comparison, but it made him seem comparable to the likes of Joffrey, (without the fact he is a product of incest, and a sociopath w/Mad King qualities) who styles himself as King by right, but does absolutely nothing, and should be obeyed w/out question.

Although he was not a POV, Robb was his father's son, and it was why Jeyne Westerling was so important. But the writers created Talisa, who not only made Robb look like an arrogant young King, but it destroyed his character. Remember that calling Robb his "father's son" is a big deal. We all know what happened to Ned, who refused to compromise his honor; he lost his head.  As I had said in my 3.09 post, Robb made a conscience choice to marry Talisa, and the adjectives used to describe him in this episode, might well have been the perception of his advisors and soldiers.

Roose Bolton & Lord Frey

The opening scene of this episode, was exactly what the RW was about: destroying Robb's army, and the North. The full scale of it as seen by Roose Bolton:

Roose "Traiterous Ass" Bolton watching his handiwork from the ramparts
Then we are treated to a little conversation between Roose and Lord Frey, in which Roose clearly thinks that Lord Frey is an ass. He reminds him that although he is Lord of Riverrun, the Blackfish (go Blackfish!) escaped the carnage; which means that being Lord of Riverrun may not be a done deal. But Lord Frey, being the genius and the best patsy ever, says "Who cares! Edumure is in the dungeons, and I have the power of the mighty Lannister's backing me up".

Yeah, well I'm Warden of the North, and you are too stupid 
to realize that losing the Blackfish, is kind of a big deal. 
Let's move on from the the fact that everyone has seen the real Roose Bolton (in the book he's a stoic, cruel man, who leaches everyday, and drinks some weird concoction), and realizing that defcon 5 psycho Ramsey, did not get that way just because he's a bastard.

Who, btw is torturing Theon, eating sausage and joking w/Theon that it is his favorite "toy". Obviously he's just eating some blood sausage, we learn how Theon, became Reek.

The Greyjoys
As usual Balon is a loving father, although he does seem a bit rattled by the "get out of the North" letter from Ramsey, and the BOX.  Asha is horrified and Balon goes back to being an a-hole, and says, well that's that! He disobeyed a direct order, I have no more sons, and he cannot give my an heir.

Moving on, Asha, says she has made up her mind, and she does not care that he disobeyed their father, but he is his son, her baby brother, and a GREYJOY. Unfortunately, it looks like Asha will not be following a path towards attempting to be Queen in the show, which is a little disappointing. I just hope that they keep Victarion and Euron (both brothers of Balon, and who have travelled, just as Asha has, way and beyond the Narrow Sea). Now, many have a problem with this desire to save her brother, as she most certainly did not last season. However, she warned Theon about remaining at Winterfell, informed him that their father had ordered him home, and his home was not in the North.

In my eyes, I finally saw the badass Asha Greyjoy, who became one of my favorite female characters in the series, has finally appeared. I love this scene of her walking past all of those dangerous men, as we hear her say:

"And I've made mine (her decision). I'm going to pick the fastest ship in our fleet and I'm going to pick the 50 best killers on the Iron Islands. I'm gong to sail up the Narrow Sea all the way to the Weeping Water and I'm going to march on the Dreadfort, and I'm going to bring him home"

This is a departure from the books, but I loved it.

Now to one final dedication: Arya Stark
I assume by now you have seen a bit of a bias in my dedications, go Arya!

When I saw our girl wake up, and see her brother's body w/his wolf's head "sewed" onto it, as the Frey's mockingly yelled "King of the North", I felt the shock and disgust that I should have felt last week. I did not think that they would go there, but they did, and I actually put my hands over my eyes, and had a few tears. The way she just collapsed into the Hound after this and then realizing that she has also lost her mother, has turned out girl into a cold blooded killer.

Arya breaking into pieces and becoming......


THIS....."Valar Morghulis", we'll see you in Braavos!

I will miss "chatty kathy" Arya, and I already miss the Arya/Gendry show,  but it is time for our little sociopath to bloom. Book Arya bloomed long ago, and had been slicing and dicing since Harrenal, so the show took a slower approach. However, Maisie Williams brought it,    as when she approached the Frey posse, with that creepy voice and dead look in her eyes,  we saw an entirely new Arya.

Remember the old days when Jaqen was recruiting her to the Faceless Men? It looks like she has made a decision, and it is a big "YES".

Jaqen to Arya on what she can achieve as a Faceless Man:

"To be a Dancing Master is a special thing. But to be a Faceless Man, that is something else entirely. The girl has many names on her lips: Joffrey, Cersei, Tywin Lannister, Ilyn Payne, The Hound. Names to offer up to the Red God. She could offer them all, one by one." (2.10)

Sexy Jaquen H'gar telling Arya 
what she can do as a Faceless Man
Oh and wait, I think that we should talk about Melisandre, right? Looks like that Red God who seems to need her to kill, oh I mean "sacrifice" 1/2 royal blood teenagers to eliminate her enemies, might be a name our girl could offer up to said god, correct? They have no interaction in the books, but here they did, and let's not kid ourselves, Mel is on that kill list, so perhaps they WILL meet again.


Speaking of Mel, let's go to Dragonstone, and see what crazy crap is coming out of her mouth these days.

Dragonstone
Stannis
I had wanted to discuss Stannis before finishing his section of the season. Admittedly, and not just because he's gotten all sexy on us, he has become one of my favorite characters. Stannis is not a POV in the book, yet he is still a man who believes in loyal/traitor, right/wrong, and is nothing like his brothers. Having fun, and getting drunk in the brothels was not his thing. However  sleeping w/a black magic psycho was fine, as she could help him get his crown.

Stannis is an honorable man, but he has a very, very strict code. It is unbending, and if you betray him, there is nothing that will save you, EVEN if you are Ser Davos. He refused to play the game by leaving Kings Landing in the early days of Robert's reign. If you betray him, you are a traitor, and you will die for it. A great example (besides Ser Davos), is how he, as most men did, had great respect for Ned. However, it did not keep him from wanting Robb dead, because he was trying to take his kingdom away.

But I always believed that he was using Mel, as a marketing tool to differentiate himself from the other "usurpers".  In the book, she did things without his knowledge, such as using him, w/black magic, to kill Renly. If I remember correctly, he did not greenlight a shadow baby to kill his brother, but he did have a dream, that he killed his brother, and he was horrified. I can't remember if he connected the dots, but it was pretty creepy that she somehow took his soul or shadow, and used magic to make it kill Renly. Afterall, Book Brienne and Cat, really saw a shadow that looked like Stannis. It was very shady, and indicated that she was using him in a scary way, for her agenda.

After Blackwater, the idea to march on the wall, did have something to do w/Mel, but the main reason was that this was how he was going to save the realm. Winter is coming, "the darkness is coming for everyone and everyhing", and he knows that the Wall, is where he will need to be.

We saw in season 2.0 that Stannis has enormous respect for Ser Davos, because he tells it like it is, could give a crap what the other Lords think of him, and in the show his conscience. I had discussed how Stannis (see Part II 3.05 & 3.06) was very humbled by his behavior, after Mel left town. When she left, his head cleared, he knew that he had dishonored his wife, and betrayed his friend. The most important part of this realization is that Stannis does not believe in the Red God, but, he believes that this god is the only weapon in his arsenal that will enable him to regain his kingdom. He has seen proof of this god's power, or he probably would have killed Mel in 2.10, if he had not seen said proof.

The desire to become King made him make that suicidal run on Kings Landing, as his ships were burning in wildfire. Remember last season when he was going all bad ass on the ramparts of Kings Landing, and he literally had to be dragged away screaming 'Nooooo!", or he would have been killed. I was actually kind of shocked how well he used that sword, it reminded me of Jon Snow, as he is quick and badass w/a sword as well.

My point is that Stannis is a man, like Davos, where there are no games being played.   Although there was a point in this episode when he looked like he was in trance, after Mel was giving her load a crap about why Robb Stark is dead, to Davos. But take note people, he is no longer under her spell.

Let's begin!

I had to merge Davos from 3.08-3.10, as it just made more sense to do so.


3.08 Davos
Many people found the Davos chapters boring, and I admit that I breezed through them second time around, but he has really come to life on screen. Liam Cunningham has made me think about the character in a whole new light, and I really like it.

I have seen Liam Cunningham as an insane sociopath on StrikeBack, as the leader of a "new earth" scifi show "Outcasts", and a powerful black magic warrior/sorceror on Merlin, amongst other great performances . He is a fantastic actor, and he has really fleshed out Davos in a way, that I am starting to see him as the "bad boy" version of Ned.

We know that Davos has grown up poor, and Stannis asks him how he has been treated, and in Davos' eyes, it has not been that bad. In fact in the book, he is really surprised as to why he is being fed so well, as he was getting stronger, not weaker. Davos has no secrets, he tells it like it is, damn the consequences.

When Stannis goes to free Davos from the dungeons, he has already met with Melisandre and seen the product of his brother's lack of honor and self control.  These are two things that disgust him, and make him angrier that he never received the credit, which he should have received after the war, for holding holding down Storm's End. It is an event that is mentioned by him in Season 2, because he held out to the end, and Davos saved them w/his onions. It was also mentioned by Lady Olenna this season, about how her son just hung out outside Storm's End, eating and living the good life, while Stannis was eating rats and horses, because he refused to give up Storm's End.

As I had said in Part II of the 3.05 & 3.06 recap, Stannis was struggling with his decisions at the behest of Mel. This is why I am loving HBO Stannis, because we see him making an attempt to find some kind of reason in the blood magic madness, by visiting Davos. Before he gets to the point, he says, what he should have said earlier, that he was sorry about his son, as he was a good, loyal boy.


 I really liked what he says to Ser Davos in his cell, before he frees him: 

"I never asked for this, no more than I asked to be King. We do not choose our destiny, but we must do our duty, no? Great or small we must do our duty. What is one bastard boy against a kingdom?"

For me, it defines that Stannis is a man who fights for his kingdom by right, not necessarily because it is something that he wants to do.  Since this is true, he will do anything to get it, and that includes using Mel and her black magic madness.  


Stannis says that he is there to free him, ONLY if he promises not to raise a hand against the Red Woman. I find it interesting how he calls her the "Red Woman", and not by her first name, when he is in the presence of those he knows that he has wronged.

Davos: "that won't keep me from saying how I feel about her, and oh, btw, you're right! I don't have much regard for my own life, so I have no problem getting real." Stannis adds that his bastard nephew has been brought to Dragonstone, and he will be sacrificed for the cause.

Davos: " Okay, but we know why you're really down here, right? You are not comfortable with killing an innocent in the name of HER god. Oh and BTW, murder and sacrifice are the same thing." 

Davos: "Fine, I saw her birth that black magic shadow baby, but Renly might have been your brother (guilt trip), but he was a traitor, (I am unflinching in my loyalty TO YOU). This boy is your nephew, an innocent, and you want me to tell you that it is wrong to burn him at the behest of the Red Woman."
"I have seen the battle in the snow, 
with my own eyes. You have seen what she can do,
 how can I deny the power of this god, 
when there is PROOF of his work?" 
Davos basically shrugs, and is like "whatever", and the next time we see him, is when poor Gendry has become a man by Melisandre, and indiscriminately given blood, via leeches, to take the place of burning him.

Mel is giving Davos, who is now Hand of the King,  the evil eye, because she knows that he is the one, who convinced Stannis not to burn Gendry. Stannis put the three leeches into the fire and names the three traitors "Robb Stark, Balon Greyjoy, and Joffrey Baratheon". As a book reader you know that, and we have seen, that this is actually the order in which these three men die. The only one who dies under "mysterious" circumstances is Balon, who falls off this scary rope ladder between the castles, which he has walked across since he was a boy. Asha hears that there was a giant wave that took him, but I think someone else had a part in his death. But that my friends is for season 4!

3.10 Davos
In this episode, we find Davos in the dungeon visiting with Gendry who is angry, and a little depressed, but not despondent! Gendry knows that he is a victim of a game that he does not understand. Gendry calls BS on Davos that he is low born. Davos tells him the story of how he had grown up in Kings Landing, at the base of High Born privy pipes. He helped Stannis out of a difficult situation once, and he made him a Lord. He also shows how he cut off his fingertips, but offers no explanation. (unless its common knowledge that when caught, a smuggler gets him fingertips cut off).

Gendry has ended up where he began, and feels like a fool for falling so easily into Melisandre's black magic sex trap. Davos actually asks him why he fell for Mel's crap, and he says that she was naked, he never had sex before, what would he have done? Well, Davos can't deny that, as he is a man afterall, and when Mel got naked, she knew that he was turned on; well until she birthed the shadow baby.

Davos tells Gendry that he did not want to be a Lord, but he did it for his son. It was really sad that when Gendry asks about his son, Davos says he is dead. The most interesting part of this conversation is that when Gendry asks how he died, Davos says "Following me". aka, LOYALTY.

It reminded me of a conversation that Arya had with King Tywin last season at Harrenhal. Remember when he asked her how her father died, she said "LOYALTY". This is the exact same response that Davos gives Gendry, although with different words and context. Well done, writers, well done.

Stannis & Melisandre
Davos is practicing reading with Shireen and reading the letters from the ravens. He has become quite good actually, or has learned enough to figure out what the letters are saying. He says that it is part of his job to go through this stuff, and then he finds the letter from the NW. But suddenly we hear the bells ringing, and he tells Shireen to lock herself in the room.

mmmm, I'm going to keep this news in my back pocket
When he goes to the "Throne Room" he sees Mel throwing the wolf chess pieces into the fire. Stannis looks like he is in a trance:

"The usurper Robb Stark is dead, 
betrayed by his banner men"
Davos is like okay, and then looks at Mel and says "I bet you think burning those leeches caused his death right? Rather than some clever planning by King Tywin". She smugly adds, no, she was rewarded by "my faith in my faith".  Sure, all those thousands of men being butchered and burnt at the beginning of the episode, were the work of R'hllor. I just waned to smack her, but in a good way, not like Cersei, who is just annoying.

Then we have a little history lesson, courtesy of Stannis, about how Aegon conquered Westeros with his three dragons (notice he says three) and magic. Stannis also mentions that the usurpers have made his kingdom bleed, and he will never forgive them for such a sin. He "will punish them with any arms at his disposal", ie. burning Gendry. Stannis is a practical man after all, and he has proof that her magic works right? But Davos does not let it go, and says that he knows that Stannis is a good man, blood magic is evil, and the world has gone to crap. Oh, and that doesn't mean we have to use evil in order to win.

Naturally Mel says "A great gift, requires great sacrifice" as she strolls over to Stannis.  What I really loved about this scene? Is that when Mel walks over to Stannis and says "My King.." and touches his shoulder and chest, which is a power move, he turns away from her to the look out at the sea. I love how "My King.." is used by Mel as a tool to manipulate Stannis. Well, it looks like Mel might have R'hllor on her side, but Stannis only needs her to look into her fires, have "suggestions", and get results. Such as these:
Devil or Angel? I've made my choice.
Oh, and Mel? ''My King.." doesn't work anymore
Stannis: "What is the life of one bastard boy for a kingdom?"
Davos: " Everything". 
Stannis: "The boy must die".

And Davos goes down to the dungeons and sets Gendry free. When Gendry asks why, Davos says "because it's right, and I'm a slow learner". 

Who does this remind us of? Ned! Our Ned, who refused to learn, and wanted things to be done, because it is right, and did not even consider that he would be betrayed. Davos knows better, and he knows that he will most likely die for setting him free. But he said screw it In fact, he even tells Stannis " I feel good! Yes, your most loyal servant (and you know this) feels good about disobeying my King, and letting Gendry go". Then we hear some blah, blah, blah, from Mel about how he has destroyed "the lives of tens of thousands", and she sounds INSANE, and I love it. Stannis is the ends justify the means type of guy, and is outraged.

Davos simply says " there are other ways of winning, and I can't see the future or read the fires, but there must be another way". Stannis  sentences him to death for destroying his ONLY other way to win the war, and betraying his King, as Mel looks on w/glee.

Suddenly, Davos, reveals that he is now a player in the game, as he is dragged away. He whips out the letter from the NW, and says "you can't stop it alone, you'll need me to convince this Lord and that Lord, and bring sellswords and pirates together.". As he holds out the letter, Stannis says, in his "I feel bad now" voice, "when did you learn to read?", Davos lies and says that his son taught him, so that he could be of better service (see I am very LOYAL, no games attached,  which is true, and why Stannis is feeling a smidge guilty) to him.

I know you are a good man, but a traitor is a traitor!
Yet, as Stannis hands off the letter to Mel, but he still wants to Davos taken away, because he betrayed his King. But Mel says "NO! He will play a part in the war to come, as the darkness is coming, and the war of the five kings means nothing.".  Only Stannis will be able to save them (yeah, we'll see about that), and Stannis starts to laugh. Why? Because, now Davos has to give in, as Mel saved his life by looking into the fires (proof is proof right?).

See Ser Davos? You are saved by that fire god you like to mock so much. You're in his army now."

Mel just looks at Davos and Davos right back at Mel:

Great, now I have to keep my mouth shut; 
that Red Witch just saved my life.

We'll visit our other characters in Part II!

All images and quotes are owned by HBO, "Game of Thrones" 3.08-3.10

Sunday, June 9, 2013

Game of Thrones 3.09: "The Rains of Castemere"

I am behind in recaps, as I need to do 3.07 & 3.08, but I needed to write about the Red Wedding as it is so fresh in my mind. I will also write about the other story lines in another posting, as they were quite good this episode.

I knew this was the first, last and only time we would see
the Stark boys together. Any image from the RW, was too upsetting, so I
put this bittersweet moment at the beginning of this entry.
The Red Wedding
Although this was not what I expected, this was still one of the best episodes of the series, with "Baelor" being the best.

There were two events that I have dreaded since Season 1: Ned's death, which still makes me well up, sick to my stomach, and the Red Wedding. But the reason Ned's death affected me so much, was how a good, honorable man's last words were everything he was not, and he got his head chopped off for it.

As a book reader, I knew from day one, that King Tywin was writing all of those letters, so he could plan this wedding. He is the only person, who is more of a sociopath than people think, and a narcissist, who could have planned such a well thought out attack.

As for the wedding itself, I was underwhelmed upon the first viewing. I was very upset after reading this event, almost, if not more than the death of Ned. It was a chaotic, drunken, bloody mess in the book, that included the great families of the North, so that we knew what the repercussions of this event meant to the future of the North and the Starks. Robb had body guards who tried to protect him, Grey Wind was chained outside, it was a nightmare. They were also drunk and rowdy, prior to the carnage, which alluded to how well planned this was, and how many of those supposedly loyal to Robb, jumped ship before it sank.

The carnage outside was seen through Arya's eyes, who knew immediately that it looked more like a battle than a wedding. There was fire, and killing everywhere.

And killing a King because he married for love, and honor, is not a slight, worth of mass murder. 

So, I am wrapping this up a bit late, as I still was getting a little weepy, but here are my thoughts.....

RW: The Book

I rewatched the episode two more times, to see if I was being too harsh in my feelings about this episode. But although horrified, this was not what I had envisioned for the HBO version of the RW. If you have not read the book, read it, and believe me, there are no words, to describe how much worse this event was on the page, than the one depicted on screen. 

I am all about The North and the Starks, being that Jon Snow is my favorite character, hands down. When I saw the burning of the Direwolf flags for 3.10, I felt devastated, as that made me feel as I did when Ned was murdered.

The RW was a brutal act of genocide planned by Lord Tywin, who as usual, got someone else to do his dirty work.  Tywin understood that everything the Frey's did that night, would taint them forever, and not the Lannister name. He  knew that the Freys were not part of the Higher Houses Club, kind of shady, and Lord Walder desperately wanted to be a player in the game. He was the perfect patsy because he was blinded by the fact he wanted his daughter to be Queen. Thus, Tywin knew that that a man like Lord Walder would not even blink about breaking traditions, because he was not exactly the most clever of men.  Afterall, Lord Walder is like the Craster of Westeros.

Tywin made sure that an important event, like the wedding of the King's Uncle, would bring all the of the great houses of the North in one place. In fact, in the book he tells Tyrion, that this way was the cheapest way to get rid of Robb & crew. Oh, and PS-he was supposed to be killed by an arrow, but the bodyguards screwed that up. So Roose, decided to take charge of the situation and use Jaime's name in vain, thinking that he was glorifying himself, by ingratiating the Lannisters. But really, all he did was add some more bonus points to his traitorous ass.  It's like I said, Tywin is a monster, he just gets other people to do his dirty work for him. Makes you wonder if Joffrey is not only a monster because he's a product of incest, but because of Tywin, right?

The marriage to Jeyne Westerling was very important because Robb proved that he was his father's son. He married Jeyne, because he slept with her after she nursed him back to health. He was 15 years old, in love, and did not fully realize the implications of his actions. If Robb had been more experienced, he would have seen that marrying Jeyne was honorable, but not worth the cost of breaking an oath to the Freys. This was war, and the stakes were high.

It is also important to remember that Robb is seen through a mother's eyes, as he is not a POV. Cat was smart, and knew from her interactions with the Freys over the years, that there could be greater repercussions for Robb's actions. I believe that Lord Walder had tried to marry some of his brood into Riverrun when she was younger, and her father had flatly refused. Lord Tywin was also angry (and added to the lack of respect that he had for his father), that his father had married his sister to a Frey, because he thought they were beneath them. Cat knew that this marriage would be more than a slight, because Lord Walder wanted his daughter to be Queen. 

Cat made sure that they ate upon their arrival, so that they would be protected by the Guest's Right. If you break this tradition which is hundreds of years old, the taint will never leave your house. But Grey Wind, was freaking out on the way in, so the reader immediately knew that something was very, very wrong. In fact, he attacked the welcoming party, and Robb could not calm him down. He had to actually get off his horse, and talk to him, so he would stop attacking Freys. In an earlier scene, Grey Wind had been barking at a Frey and Cat begged Robb to send him away, (he does, even though he thought she was overreacting) because she knew that the wolves were special, and Grey Wind always knew when someone was dangerous. But Robb had to kiss up to Lord Frey so he could get his men, and make amends for breaking an oath.

He was very angry that he had to leave Grey Wind outside, as the Freys tried to put him in a kennel (as they do in the show), and Robb tells them that he's a direwolf, not a dog. Everyone knew that Grey Wind could take out a large group of people without a problem, (he's the size of a pony & likes throats) and would have protected Robb, until either he or Robb were killed. Thus, the Freys asked Robb to chain him up outside, before he entered the Hall. 

The path to Robb's death was very similar to that of his father's; he put too much faith in loyalty and honor. He even says that he was always trying to rule as his father did, and had trouble understanding why Karstark, in particular had betrayed him. But the other strong houses of the North remained loyal, and supported his decision to name Karstark a traitor, and to kill him as such; kinsman or not. A huge part of Robb as King of the North, was the unflinching loyalty of the great leaders, like the Greatjon.

Some ask if Ned had run this campaign, would he have lost his life for the same reasons? No, because he was older, an experienced fighter, and would have made smarter choices. Ned was an anomaly of a man in Westeros (except for Jaime, who never cheated on Cersei), who as far as I understood, never cheated on Cat (I do not think that he is Jon's father). If Robb had been older, and knew the gray world of Westeros, he probably could have taken back the North. Ned lost his life, not because of his honor code on the battlefield, he just refused to compromise it, so he could play the Game. 

RW: HBO & some Book
We all know that they had to age up all of the characters because they were too young to be doing certain things like: Arya becoming a soicopath at 9 years old, and Dany having sex at 13 years old. 

I liked the fact they aged Robb up, and gave him a bigger part in the show, as he did not have a POV. But Richard Madden is in his late 20's, he was physically much larger between season one and two, which was good, as it made his being King of the North, more believable. He was always impressive in his full Stark gear, and when he had conversations with Karstark for example, he spoke to him, man to man. As we saw in S2, he inspired loyalty amongst his men, and that was impressive for someone so young. He was supposed to be 17, but I easily forgot that he was that young, as he made his decisions w/conviction. They showed him walking amongst his men, as any good leader does, to make sure he is in contact with his men. Cat warned him, when she saw him drooling over Talisa, that he was his father's son. Ned fulfilled his obligation after Brandon was murdered, and he needed to keep his oath to the Freys.

The choice to marry Talisa, was in complete juxtaposition to the man we had seen throughout most of S2. The writers should not have made him look so oblivious to the consequences of his actions. Robb was a smart, honorable man, and this made him look like a foolish boy king. Talisa was from Volantis and the people of Westeros did not care about anyone beyond the Narrow Sea. He could have been w/her, married the Frey girl, and she would have vanished.

It also diminished the huge influence that Ned had upon Robb as a ruler. It made him look selfish, not honorable, because he put his own feelings above winning back the North, and defeating the Lannisters.  Marrying Jeyne Westerling, was a bad move, but at least we saw that it was about youth, love and it reiterated the cost of truly being his father's son.

His love for Talisa, never should have been above winning back the North, and that is what it started to look like to me. Even though they had the second damning moment of his campaign: killing Karstark, as something that only Ned's son would do, the damage to his character had been done.

The most annoying moment of all, was when we had to listen to:  "we're so happy and in love, and guess what? I'm pregnant and I'm going to tell my mom, and oh honey, you're the best. Oh, and then when you win, you can come to Volantis and meet her!" Go to Volantis? Are you kidding me with this? Yes, that's what the King of the North would do, especially after all that he would have to do to win it back. Plus, winter REALLY is coming. 

HOWEVER,  I really liked the final scene between him and Cat, when he apologizes or as much as a man/son could, and that he should have listened to her about Theon. He says that she was right about Theon, and that cost him Winterfell, his brothers, and the North. The attack of Casterly Rock was a huge risk even w/the Frey army behind him, and both he and his mother were aware that they could end up like Ned, or worse. It was go big, or go home, because as Cat said, she wanted vengeance. This was a bold plan, and I began to see a tiny glimpse of our King of the North again; even though I knew that the end was near. 

But that moment disappeared pretty quickly, as Robb & Talisa were all lovey, dovey at the wedding, and the tension was palpable.  When they are talking about baby names at the event right before the killing begins, it was supposed to make her murder, more poignant.  But again, it was a waste of a scene, as we already knew about the baby, and he should have been more aware of his surroundings.

It was also unfortunate they did not have the GreatJon there, although small clues of the other houses being there, were seen by the reader. Plus, Robb might have been in love, but he was not fool enough to act that way (Talisa did stop him the first time) and further insult Lord Frey.  Frankly, I did not think he was quite so comfortable in the book, as he wanted out of there, and to be done with it. But this Robb seemed relieved that the wedding was done, ignored the uneasy feeling in the room, and forgot that the woman beside him was the reason that he was there in the first place.

I also did not like how Roose deliberately let Cat see the armor beneath his shirt. I know it was done to show that he was sticking it to her for setting Jaime free, but it ruined the shock value. In the book, she sees the mail by accident on a Frey, as he shuts the door. Roose was a traitor, plain and simple, and I think that he was on the verge of jumping ship, when they arrived at Harrenhall and saw the dead bodies. Remember he was telling Karstark that he had his best hunters looking for Jaime as they were watching Robb and Talisa look at the dead Northerners?  Makes your remember this line:

"You lost the war, the day you married her", Lord Karstark to the King of the North.

Roose did not want to end up w/his head on a pike next to Ned's. When they were eating & drinking at the reception and he is w/Cat and the BlackFish, he states that he had married a Frey and was now a very rich man...hint, hint, Lannister gold?

After Edmure and his wife were bedded, Cat heard the song, and saw the doors being locked. Lord Frey silenced the room, and speaks to Robb, so that so he will be in position to be hit by the arrows. Roose does his show and tell, Cat slapped him, and he dashed to the other side of the room. Cat screams at Robb to run, and the first thing we see is Talisa looking confused, and then brutally stabbed in the stomach, as Robb watches in shock and is taken down by the arrows. Watching the soldier going straight for Talisa's stomach, made the betrayal seem all the more palpable, because they knew she was pregnant, and deliberately ensured (or thought they did) that the Stark line was now dead. 

The carnage begins as throats are slit, arrows fly, and the room is in total chaos. Lord Frey is laughing as he watched the slaughter of the North, and even mocks Robb "look at the King of the North now", as he drags himself to Talisa's body. It was nauseating...But Cat saved that final scene, as I was still in shock over Talisa. Robb pushes himself up to stand, he turns to Cat and says "Mother", Roose kills him, and says the famous line about the Lannisters (sans Jaime). Cat's scream sealed the deal, and her grief brought Robb's death up to and beyond that of Talisa's, because she watched her first and (and who she thought was her last living child), murdered before her eyes. He was all she had left, and then she slits the Frey girls throat, someone slits hers, and black.

Arya
Our dear girl, although saved by the Hound, is once again at the scene of the death of her family. In this case it was her mother and brother, and it's like watching Ned die all over again. You can see the hope in her eyes as she jumps out of the wagon, and watches the Northerners partying. But then she starts to look worried because Grey Wind is going insane & is locked up.  It looks as if she is about to set Grey Wind free, but suddenly Northerners are being slaughtered, Grey Wind is killed, and the Hound knocks her out.

Unfortunately, this is the last straw, and Arya will become a lost soul, and is just done. Vengeance will be the only thing that will sustain her, and I look forward to seeing Maisie Williams show Arya go stone cold, as we will follow on her journey to Braavos in S4. It will lead her to, you guessed it, the temple where her training to become one of the Faceless Men shall begin.

Since the finale is tonight, I do not want to discuss Dany, Jon and Bran in 3.09. But I will talk about them and the characters we saw in 3.07/3.08 in a separate posting, after I complete 3.10.

Next up: 3.10 Part I "Mhysa"  (important events from 3.07 & 3.08 were merged in 3.10 Part I)

*"Images and Quotes courtesy of HBO's "Game of Thrones"3.09










Sunday, June 2, 2013

GOT: Part II 3.05 "Kissed by Fire" & 3.06 "The Climb"

Part II of this post will only focus on the characters who had smaller, but not insignificant story arcs.

Lets just get rid of Theon now,
Theon
He's still being tortured by Ramsey, who blows a horn and decides to play the "where are we, and who am I" game, and skins his finger. This is just a waste of valuable screen time, and I think by now, that the audience knows who Ramsey is, and that he is a defcon 5 psycho. I can only pray we will no see him again until 4.10.

Sam
Well, thankfully Ghost has realized that Sam is not Jon, and has not followed him on his journey back to the wall. However, Sam is with Gilly and her son, and they are sitting by a fire, and he eventually breaks into song. He also tells Gilly all about the delicious food at Castle Black, as she schools him on the best way to make a fire. 

Basically, this scene is to show everyone that Sam has an obsidian dagger and it will be used very, very soon. 

Bran
Meera and Osha are competing at "who can skin the rabbit" faster and better than the other.

Bran is annoyed, and tells them to stop fighting, and get over themselves, and they stop bickering. During this lovely discussion, Jojen starts having a seizure and Meera runs over to help him, as apparently HBO Jojen has seizures while he has visions. So, he wakes up, and tells them that Jon is on the wrong side of the wall and he is surrounded by enemies.

King of the North
One of the great things about this series, is how it reiterates how important Ned is to the story. The moment in 1.01 when he kills the deserter of the NW, has turned out to be an act that deeply affected both Jon and Robb. In fact it is so important, that it defines who they become as men. If you recall, Ned said " The man who passes the sentence, should swing the sword.".  This means that if you are brave enough to be the accuser, you are brave enough to do the deed. But this was our dear Ned, who was an honorable, brave, man, whose values got him killed, and began a war.

Continuing on...Karstark has finally gotten vengeance for his sons by killing the Lannister boys. So Robb does a Ned, and decides that Karstark must die for betraying him, even though it will cost him all of Karstark's men. He sentences him to death, because he is a traitor. Meanwhile, we see his family looking on, as they know Robb's decision will affect his campaign, and not in a good way.

But Karstark was not just any man, he was a Stark. He was loyal to his father, The North, and is Robb's kinsman. Robb is enraged, while at the same time, he is clearly distraught, by his decision. This is evident, in the powerful moment, when he throws the sword down after killing Karstark, and walks away in the rain. Yet, he would rather loose the men, than be seen (in his mind as weak) because he did not kill a traitor. However, he was already losing control of his campaign because of what his mother did, his marriage to Talisa, and may now be named the kinslayer who has betrayed the North.

The scene when Robb beheads Karstark was as foreshadowing as the moment when Ser Rodrick told Theon "Gods help you Theon Greyjoy" before he was beheaded. Karstark says that he has no problem dying for what he did, and his final words are: "Kill me and be cursed. You are no King of mine.".

Robb making the second 
biggest mistake of his life
The result of this catastrophic decision is that Robb has to crawl back to the Freys, because he needs them in order to conquer Casterly Rock. They are a sorry bunch, but they decide that in order to make up for the insult of Robb marrying Talisa, (I still wish they had kept Jeyne, as the reason he married her, showed how he is truly his father's son), Edmure will have to marry a Frey. Poor Edmure, he is once again looking like a total loser, because he has to do whatever Robb and his uncle tell him to do, for THE NORTH. In addition, he is paying for his nephew's mistakes, who at least has the decency to admit that Edmure is paying for his actions.

Dragonstone
Is it me or is Stannis looking hotter every week? If he looks this good every time Melisandre goes on a trip for some more King's Blood, I say, she should leave him more often.

I will preface this by saying that Stannis was so distraught over his loss at the Blackwater, that he let Melisandre do things, he would not have otherwise done; ie. burning the so called traitors. We saw in 2.10, how angry he is at Melisandre, and himself for believing that she would help him to win the war. He let her commit horrible acts in the name of a god, that he never believed in. Yet, as we book readers knew, she took back control of  the situation, and had him look into the flames, and see a battle in the snow; season 4 people, season 4.

2.10: Stannis realizing that his obsession, 
has cost him his honor.
So far in S3, we have seen a depressed, broken Stannis. He has been greatly humanized for the show, as in the book he is always portrayed as a stoic, harsh man, who does not interact w/his child and daughter in any meaningful way, if he ever does at all. He is also sleeping with Melisandre, who is acting as his defacto Queen and Hand of the King. Presently, we know that he has been sleeping with Melisandre, and she has been acting in the same manner, and has had enormous influence over his actions.

I love what has been done with his character, and you can see, particularly in his interaction with his wife, the weight of breaking his marriage vows, and the realization that he let Melisandre control his life. But crazy Selyse opens her mouth, and Melisandre comes out of it. She keeps saying that the Lady Melisandre has kept her up to speed, and that he is King, and he can do whatever he likes, ie.cheat on her. Stannis is no fool, and he sees how Melisandre has manipulated his wife into thinking, "I can't give you sons, but Melisandre can give you all the sons you need to be King. Dishonor me all you want! In fact you honor me by breaking your vows, and letting her give you what I cannot."

Confessing to Selyse that he has sinned.

Sexy Stannis: 
Horrified by Selyse's reaction to his confession


He also has the pleasure of seeing, but turning his back on the "sons" that Selyse has kept, no doubt at the behest of Melisandre. Kings blood, is Kings blood right? I guess if Gendry doesn't work out, she would need some back-up, since there are no more Baratheon bastards in town.

My hot husband, look at all of my dead sons
Stannis leaves his zealot wife, to go see his daughter, who unfortunately has greyscale.

Daddy you're here!

Greyscale seems to come from the sea, and normally will cause death, but some survive. My impression from the books, is that the skin is thick and grey, like an old statue, that has cracked. Shireen survived and her face is severely deformed because of it. So, this is Shireen "light", but she remains a sweet child.

Stannis is clearly uncomfortable with the joy of his daughter, (strong emotional reactions are not really his thing), upon seeing her father and giving him a big hug. Shireen asks about Davos, who has apparently been visiting her, in her not so ivory tower. As she is holding a toy ship that Davos had given her, Stannis says that Davos fought bravely, and honorably in the war. However, he is a traitor and is in the dungeons, so "she best forget about him". In other words, "I am trying to forget the pain & guilt of knowing that although Davos tried to kill Melisandre, I put my most loyal, and trusted advisor into a dungeon without blinking, because SHE told me to. Gods, what have I done.".

Wow! I had no idea that I had so much to say about Stannis! But he does look super sexy right? Let's look at him again:

Sexy, non?
Kings Landing
King Tywin vs. Lady Olenna

One of the best scenes in the series are these two powerhouses facing off about Cersei and Loras. I love how this goes down as a business deal, as they both have a big bad secret.  The worse kept secrets, but nonetheless, they would destroy their houses.
So in short:

Lady Olenna: "Cersei is too old to bear children and I do not want her to marry Loras.".
KingTywin: "No way, Cersei is the most beautiful woman in the realm. Oh and PS  I know Loras is gay, ( or as he says "this affliction") so you have to do what I want."
Lady Olenna: "Yeah whatever, I know about the twincest and that would put a stain on MY house. Oh, and I already know that he is gay, and so does everyone else. Bye the bye, you did you not experiment in your youth?"
King Tywin: "First, twincest is a viscous lie (he so knows it is not, but would never admit it to himself)., and if Loras does not marry my daughter, I will make him a member of the KingsGuard. What does that mean? The Highgarten line will die. Shall I draw up the order?".
Lady Olenna: " Aahh, you have lived up to your reputation, and you have won the battle. Cersei shall marry Loras." And she breaks the quill in half.

Lady Olenna: 0 
King Tywn: 1

On a side note: Isn't it interesting that Tywin threatens to use Loras, in the way The Mad King used Jaime by making him a member of the KingsGuard? Jaime figured that out at a later date, but KingTywin never forgot. In fact he found it so clever, that he added it to his own playbook.

Lord Varys vs. Littlefinger
This is another great moment that is not from the book. The scenes between these two men have been some of the most amazing moments of the series. The show has portrayed Littlefinger as a man who wants it all, which includes the Iron Throne. In fact, he tells Varys how many swords that compose said throne. They have a little chat in the Throne Room, wherein we discover that Littlefinger knows that Roz was working for Varys, and "was a bad investment".

But what a coincidence! He knows a man who wanted to try something new, aka King Sociopath,who was oh so grateful, that Littlefinger gave him Roz to fulfill this request.

I will digress for a moment: Roz has been a problem for me, ever since she appeared in season one.  She has wasted valuable screen time that should have been used for telling the real story. However, I would be disgusted if the writers wrote Roz for the sole purpose of reminding us that King Sociopath is quickly becoming worse than the Mad King:
  • King Sociopath killed a woman for fun, so that he could test out his new crossbow. 
  • Littlefinger has outwitted Varys, and his punishment for using Roz as his spy, was giving her to Joffrey. The horrified look on Varys face said it all, because he knows Roz has now died a horrible, long and painful death, to the sounds of laughter, courtesy of King Sociopath. 
CHECKMATE.
Then Littlefinger says to Varys, exactly what Varys said to Lady Olenna: He is so dangerous, that he would be King of ashes to get what he wants.

Varys: " I did what I did for the good of the realm." 
Littlefinger: "The realm. Do you know what the realm is? It is a thousand blades of Aegon's enemies. A story we agree to tell each other over and over until we forget that it is a lie."
Varys: But what do we have left if we abandon the lie? Chaos. A gaping pit, waiting to swallow us all.

The episode concludes with Littlefinger's voiceover:

"Chaos isn’t a pit. Chaos is a ladder. Many who try to climb it fail and never get to try again. The fall breaks them. And some are given a chance to climb, they cling to the realm or the gods or love. Only the ladder is real. The climb is all there is."

As we see King Sociopath walk away from the dead body of Roz, and Sansa weeping as she watches Littlefinger sail away. Brilliant and Powerful


That concludes Part II, and straight to 3.09: The Rains of Castemere.

*"Images and Quotes courtesy of HBO's "Game of Thrones" 3.05 & 3.06


Thursday, May 23, 2013

GOT: Part I 3.05 "Kissed by Fire" & 3.06 "The Climb"

I am behind in my recaps, but I decided to combine 3.05 & 3.06 for certain characters as it was influencing what I wrote for 3.05.

I loved 3.05, it was a fantastic episode, and although 3.06 was not as good, as a book reader you can see all the setups for what is to come in the next 4 episodes. There were some changes and additions that were both good and bad.
Part I will focus on Arya, Jaime and Jon

Part I Dedication: Arya Stark

Arya Stark
Arya has not completely grasped that her reality will never live up to what she wants it to be. These two episodes have solidified her belief that not only does she have to take care of herself, but vengeance will be hers.

My girl never ceases to amaze me, and believe me at this point in the book, she has become a full blown killer. This took place at Harrenhall, but as you know the HBO experience was not bloody and violent, but actually quite tame. However, it worked, so I took it. I believe in "Feast of Crows" is where I realized just how ruthless, and virtually a sociopath, she had actually become.

Arya desperately hoping Beric will kill the Hound

Continuing on......She has once again forgotten the warning her father had given her in Season One. If you recall, after a fight w/Sansa, Ned reminds her that they are in a very dangerous place. This means that she must not be rash (keep her mouth shut) and not be impulsive, as that is what killed Lyanna and Brandon.

So in the Bat Cave, the fight between Beric's flaming sword and the Hound has begun. The fear on the Hound's face when he saw the flames, was palpable, and Beric almost bested him. But in one wrong move, Beric got  a big chunk cut out of the right side of his body and died for the sixth time. Qyburn runs over and starts saying the words to resurrect him, and Arya goes insane.

She grabs a sword, and starts racing towards the Hound, until Gendry grabs her. The Hound says something about Micah, to rile her up, while she is screaming Burn in hell!" while Gendry holds her down.

"Burn in Hell!!"

It is actually heartbreaking to watch her during this episode because she shows two very different emotions. We see the anger, and hatred that is beginning to consume her, as we see her through the flames. But when Sandor defeats Beric, she can't take it any more, even more so when they set him free.

On the other side of the coin, we see that one slim thread that is keeping a tiny bit of hope alive, just about snaps, when Gendry tells her that he is staying with the Brotherhood. Arya says that she could be his family, he said no, "you will always be My Lady", and the look on her face, and his, was heart breaking. They have been each other's support and family for about a year, and they do not want to be separated.

Gendry, looks so sad telling Arya 
why he will never be her family.
"No, You will always be My Lady"
Our heartbroken girl
realizing why she is losing her BFF
For all of the people who think there is a little love thing going on, there is not. However, in the book, she is 9, and he is about 14, and at one point he is kind of flirting w/her. But she has no clue what is going on, finds him annoying and tells him to go away. I think she might even fight him off, as if he were the enemy. And honestly, I do not think that he knew what he was doing either, plus she was too young anyway.

In this case, I think they have a similar relationship, but they are not even close, on the verge, cusp, whatever of being in love. They love each other as friends, and I think as brother and sister.

In this case, Arya is once again disappointed by her reality, ie. even though she and Gendry are BFF's, he is right. Thoros is also very honest when he tells her that they need the gold from Robb at Riverrun, not because she is their captive.

We see that great scene with Thoros getting drunk but the fire, and Beric talking to Arya; who PS, is not afraid of him. He tells her how many times Thoros has brought him back, and they have a brief convo about how resurrection is no big deal, and  PS here are all the ways he died. However, Beric does say that everytime he comes back, a little piece of him gets chipped away. In the book, he is not quite as good looking, and it takes longer than 30 seconds for him to be revived. I believe that he actually tells Thoros to stop bringing him back, after 7x.

A good way to look at it, is if you watched Torchwood.  The gorgeous and immortal Jack Harkness (also a character from Dr.Who ), has died too many times to count, but he has a conversation with his best friend, Gwen, who asks him a question about it. He says "I have died a thousand times, and each time I come back, it is like being dragged across broken glass....", meaning it changes a man.

I digress, but the saddest moment was when she asked Thoros if he could put a man's head back on his body. Qyburn sadly says "No child", and you can see that tiny bit of a little girl that was still in there, getting smaller and smaller.

Next we see Arya learning how to be an amazing killer, I mean archer. She is beginning her quest of being amazing at all weaponry, so she can start knocking some names off her kill list.

Arya & Melisandre
Our girl thinks she hears something, and it is none other than The High Priestess, Melisandre. This is one of my favorite scenes in this episode. She has clearly brought her zealot self to grab some King's blood. Who would that be? GENDRY. She immediately speaks in High Valyrian to Thoros. She says in greeting, "Valar Morghulis", and and Thoros replies "Valar Dohaeris".

Arya hears her password, given to her by Jaqen, and knows something is very, very wrong. She even says to Gendry ..." I don't like that woman."  As we know, Jaqen gave her the words to find him, and learn to be one of the Faceless Men . Remember he did inform her that she could start ticking names off her list if he came w/him to Braavos and become one of the Faceless Men. I know that I have said it many times, but here and in the book, I could swear Jaqen was at Harrenhal to recruit Arya, because he always knew who she was.

Melisandre walks into the Bat Cave, chatting in High Valyrian with Thoros, and we learn how he failed in his mission to convert Aerys, and converted to drinking w/Robert. She meets Beric, and is shocked! shocked! That a drunk like Thoros, who is not even close to being her High Priestess Self, has brought a man back to life 6x. When she asks how that is possible, and Thoros, simply says,"I said the words and he came back to life, and I just wanted my friend back."

I really love the reason why Thoros gives Mel for bringing Beric back, as it enables you to understand the Brotherhood's devotion to R'hllor. I mean seriously, if you were a drunk and just said the words, and it actually WORKED, it would make anyone a believer. It also speaks to the different aspects of R'hllor. As Thoros said,he  just wanted his friend back, so it was love, which is a strong positive emotion.. When I compare this to Melisandre, who makes R'hllor seem like an evil god, that enables her to be a witch and sorceress, who cleanses people using fire, and making shadow babies.

Continuing on...She asks Beric what its like on the other side, and he says "There is no other side. I have been to the darkness my Lady".  So much for a sparkling afterlife, even though your are burning people in his name, expecting that you will have one.

Melisandre leaves the cave, and we learn that she has given the Brotherhood enough gold, for GENDRY.   Arya flips a lid and asks Beric "Did the Lord of Light tell you that, or did she?" , while she is having a staring contest w/Melisandre. An excellent and very smart question, right? Thoros says they need the gold to help the people, and this is what The Lord of Light wants from them.

You don't fool me witch, 
and I just added you to my kill list
Gendry freaks out, as does Arya who grabs one of the guards to stop them from taking Gendry. Melisandre looks at Gendry and says "You are more than they can ever be. They are just foot soldiers. You will make kings.".  I'm sure that is really helpful, since people in Westeros think people like Melisandre are witches, and they believe in the Seven.

He's like WTF, and well, and we know he will most likely be burnt as a sacrifice to R'hllor, bled to death, or perhaps create a shadow baby?  He is hotter and younger than Stannis, so he'd be a candidate for shadow baby making.  However that is irrelevant to Gendry, as he is basically thrown into a wagon, while yelling that he thought they were his brothers.

Arya is seething, all the while losing complete respect for The Brotherhood, who are now traitors, because they sold her best friend to some crazy looking red priestess.  So, our girl walks up to Melisandre,whips her around , and and says "You're a witch. You're going to hurt him". Quite astute for a little thirteen year old, don't you think?

Melisandre, turns and grabs her face and looks into her eyes, and informs her that she sees a darkness in her, and that there are brown, blue, & green eyes staring back at her. Arya will also shut these eyes forever.  She informs Arya that they will meet again, and leaves with Gendry. Faceless Men anyone?

The Prophesy of Arya, courtesy of Melisandre
Will they meet again? I have no idea...as by the end of ADWD, Arya has already gotten her glamor on, and has been sent off for her first apprenticeship as a member of the Faceless Men.

But, Arya is just about finished with the real world. People turning brothers in for gold, and for a god, that in her mind, does not exist. In fact, she does not believe in any gods anymore. But she looks scared while Melisandre looks into her eyes. Then we see her look very sad, because she will probably never see Gentry again. She's not as dangerous or as ruthless quite yet, but now, they can put her on the the dark path to becoming that little sociopath we know and love.

Arya watching her BFF be taken away
Jaime & Brienne
Jaime and Brienne finally arrive at Harrenhall, and Roose Bolton is not pleased that Jaime is sans hand. He takes it from his neck, and muddy, dirty Jaime falls to the ground. He sends him to Qyburn, and sends Brienne somewhere so she can get cleaned up, as she is still a Lady

We see Jaime with Qyburn, who first informs him that his hand is infected and he may have to take off his arm. Jaime says no way, and grabs him around the neck and informs him that he can still kill w/his left hand. He also asks why Qyburn has lost his Maester's chain? He says that his methods of gaining more knowledge in his profession, were unconventional. Mmmm, I don't even want to know what they are, but he informs Jaime that he will have to pick away the infection and wash it out w/hot wine. He can give Jaime the anesthesia of Westeros, milk of the poppy. Jaime says no way, he wants to be sober.  In the book, he was either afraid of being poisoned, or put in a position of even greater weakness, which is why he went hardcore. Now we get that famous conversation:

Qyburn: "It will hurt"
Jaime: "I'll scream"
Qyburn: "A great deal of pain"
Jaime: "I'll scream very loudly."

So we leave Jaime screaming his lungs out, and we move to Brienne. Brienne is very clean, and is obsessively scraping dirt off her skin, when Jaime appears. She moves into the corner of the bath, which is steaming, because she has never been naked in front of a man.

I must add, that this Brienne, even though they try to make her look manly, has beautiful skin, and as much as they try, she is played as more masculine, but not ugly. I know that the actress is a model, and if you have seen her on the red carpet, she is stunning.  The Brienne in the books, is muscular, barely any breasts, and really does look more like a man than a woman. So, Jaime decides that he will join her in the bath, and Brienne, looking horrified, says there are other baths. He is just like don't worry, I'm not interested. Then he says something else regarding Renly and how Brienne clearly did not do a good job protecting him, and Brienne stands up, all angry. He says that he is sorry, and that he should not have said that, and it was unworthy of him. He even adds that she is the only person he trusts, and that he knows that she will get him safely to Kings Landing.

Gorgeous Jaime, who still looks quite good even all dirty, as he brings his sexy self to the bath. I wish that he would have actually started to scrub off all of the dirt. Anyway, he is sitting in the corner, slowly passing out from the heat, and most likely the trauma of having pieces of what remains of his hand, picked out.

The viewer learns the true story about why he killed The Mad King, as the book reader knows the story from his POV's, and another scene that he had w/book Cat. He tells her that he was w/Aerys, and they knew that Robert had won the day at The Trident.

Jaime telling Brienne why he killed the Mad King

Tywin was at the gates of Kings Landing, and Jaime kept telling Aerys to surrender, as he knew that his father was not entering Kings Landing to support Aerys. Aerys does let him in, and Tywin proceeds to do what  is now called the Sack of Kings Landing. Remember Tywin is more a monster than people realize, because he just gets other people to do his dirty work, ie. The Mountain killing the Targaryen children.

Aerys ordered Jaime to go get his father's head, while at the same time, he reveals that his pyromancers (one of whom he appointed Hand of the King) had strategically placed wildfire all around the city. I may have mentioned it earlier, but Jaime questioned his oath, as he and the other members of the KingsGuard witnessed some horrific things. He was probably about 17 at the time he killed the King? But he was fourteen when he became a member of the KingsGuard. He was always told he was not there to question what the King did, but to guard him.

I have always thought the turning point for him was when he saw Rickard Stark boil to death, while Brandon Stark, strangled himself trying to cut the rope so he could free his father.  500 people watched this happen, while the Mad King laughed as Ned's father was screaming. I believe that I mentioned this in a prior post, but he tells Ned about this, in season 1, and he was like whatever, oathbreaker.  I also remember when Robert asks him what the Mad King said to him when he stabbed him in the back? and he said, "the same thing that he had been saying all night, 'burn them all' ". Robert looked at him, like huh? Because no one would ever think Jaime, let alone a Lannister would save others; and well, his father WAS sacking the city.

Jaime tells Brienne, that he killed the pyromancer on his way out, and stabbed the King in the back, and slit his throat, so he would never be able to give the order. This is why there was all that wildfire chez pyromancer last season, and Tyrion was wondering why there was so much and now you non-book readers know why.  He asks Brienne, what would you have done? This is where one of his best quotes is so appropriate:

"So many vows...they make you swear and swear. Defend the King, Obey the King. Keep his secrets. Do his Bidding. Your life for his.  But obey your father. Love your sister. Protect the innocent.  Defend the weak. Respect the gods. Obey the laws. Its too much. No matter what you do, you're forsaking one vow for another."

(I referred to this in 3.03, as he says this to Jon Snow in 1.01, to tell him that oaths are not all that they are cracked up to be). Jaime knows all to well that this is not a world of black & white, it is all grey, and messy. If you noticed that anyone who was honorable, is either dead, listening to a witch, or fired from a job, that is for life (Ser Barristan). King Tywin certainly does not have honor, does he? This is why it is so important in 1.01, when Jaime says a version of this quote to Jon. Ned only saw black & white, Jon really did know nothing, until he was with the wildlings. Robb, well, I think he is trying to make smart choices, but it is not working. Oh and Dany? I don't think honor is in her vocabulary (she thinks it is, because she grants slaves their freedom), but unflinching loyalty is most definitely in it.

Brienne asks him why no one knows this story? He said that Ned Stark found him there, as he arrived to secure the throne for Robert. But this was probably the one time when being a Lannister gained him nothing, as his father was sacking the city, and Jaime killing Aerys to be King? It was not too far fetched. Jaime says "What right does the wolf have to judge the lion?" . This was such a contrast to what he says about Ned to his father in s1: "Poor Ned Stark, brave man, terrible judgement". And oh so true....

"What right does the wolf have to judge the lion?"
None honey, but sadly, you are a lion. 
Jaime is about to pass out, but Brienne catches him and says "Someone help! the Kingslayer needs help!", and he says (in the book he thinks it) "my name is Jaime, its Jaime". 
Have you fallen in love yet?

Dinner Time at Harrenhall
Dinner time w/Roose, Brienne and Jaime, is nothing but filled w/great food and conversation.  Roose says that Jaime needs to promise to tell his father that he had nothing to do w/removing his hand. Brienne, is wearing the ugly pink dress, which was too big on her, when in the book it is too tight and makes her look even less attractive. At this point, Jaime, has unsuccessfully, made attempts to cut his meat. Brienne takes the fork and cuts it for him. He is also informed that Brienne will not be going with him to Kings Landing. Jaime does not like this at all, not one bit.

Jon Snow
Alas Jon is still w/out Ghost, and has some short conversation w/Orel (who clearly hates him), and Tormund about the number of castles and men at Castle Black. Orel, in eagle mode, had done a fly by, and noticed patrols and they need the lowdown. Jon tells them that 3 castles are occupied: Eastwatch by the Sea, Grey Watch, and Castle Black. In addition the patrols change every day, and include Rangers and Builders. There are 1000 men still at Castle Black. Orel and Tormund are like no way (and they are correct), and all the while Ygritte is defending Jon, Orel says something inappropriate to her, and Jon says with conviction "1000 men".

I was actually feeling a lot better about Jon at this moment, as he was suddenly acting like, well, Jon. But then it was all ruined, when he and Ygritte walk away, and he gets all whiney about her not having to protect him. So they have this whole exchange where she says that he owes her, steals his sword, and makes him chase her into the cave. Ugh.

The cave is a big deal in the book, because it is actually the penultimate moment of their relationship, not the beginning of it, as they had been in love for many months. Alas, the show destroys a moment once again, and it seemed like the writers just threw in this scene, because they had too, because it was huge in the books. They are adorable together, but when Ygritte says that she never wanted to leave the cave, it made no sense. The reason why she wanted to stay in the cave in the book, was because she wanted them to stay together forever. It is why the moment so special, and even more so, later on in his story.

The Wall & The Wildlings
The awesome Tormund Giantsbane who still is not as rowdy as he is in the books, and most certainly not as much fun. He is also very close with Jon, he also gets Jon, and knows that Jon is more wildling than he thinks that he is. In fact Jon is told this on several occasions, and even more so in ADWD. Alas, Tormund's amazing self, is not shown here, and he just states that the trees, which are all overgrown, is an indication about how far the NW has fallen.

Well, we finally reach the wall, and while Ygritte and Jon are prepping for the big 700 foot, climb of a wall bound by spells, they talk relationship. Ygritte says that she has always dreamed of seeing what the world looked like from the wall, and  it is made clear that they are in love. She also reminds him that she knows that he still has some Crow in him, but she does not care. Why? Because in the end, they are nothing to their leaders, and that together, they are one. Lovely...but Ygritte was Wildling through and through, and never told Jon, that she had an inkling that he was a spy.

Well, they reach the wall, begin the big climb, and we see in the distance that there are other wildlings climbing the wall as well. I had a problem with this whole scene, because one of the characters, amongst many who are attempting the climb, is married to a woman named Val. Val is a very important character in Jon's future, and she is also the sister of Mance's wife, who was pregnant at the time, and dies in childbirth. I am sure Val will appear at some point, but probably either in S4. or S5. But Book Jon also notes, as he begins the climb, all the bodies hanging on the tree as they fall down.  One of these men, is Jarl, who is Val's husband.
Crap, I do not want to climb the wall, 
but I'll do it for the cause
So, as they are climbing up the wall, Ygritte causes a crack, and she and Jon both fall. Orel was going to cut him off, so he would fall and die, but they manage to save each other. Eventually they reach the top, and after catching their breath, Jon takes her to the edge, and they see a magnificent view. They start making out, and I knew that the show has made this the penultimate moment in their ship. It was a great scene, so I'll take it, because it replaced what the cave did, in the book.

The show has been showing all along how Jon and Orel have big problems, and are setting up, Jon vs. Orel. In the books he had already killed Orel, because he was part of that group that he attacked w/the Half-Hand and met Ygritte.

Alas, I have to bemoan the loss of Ghost again. I know people love their dragons, and I think that is where all the direwolf money is going, and it does great damage to Jon's arc. Ghost was a big part of Jon's ability to "blend" in w/the wildlings. When he is threatened, Ghost is either beside him, or watching from a distance. However, at this point Jon had already let Ghost go, and told him to find him at Castle Black.

That ends Part I of 3.05 & 3.06, see you for Part II!

**Images and quotes courtesy of HBO's "Game of Thrones" 3.05 & 3.06